CSK Obtains Summary Judgment in Favor
of Transportation Engineering Firm

September 15, 2021

Bob de Flesco of CSK’s Ft. Lauderdale West office and Mitchell Rozen of CSK’s Miami office recently obtained final summary judgment in favor of Stantec Consulting Services, a transportation engineering firm. Stantec was sued as a result of a 2015 automobile accident that occurred in Miami-Dade County in which a vehicle carrying a family of five was forced off the road by a hit-and-run driver and crashed into the unprotected end of a concrete barrier wall separating the travel and exit lanes. All five family members were significantly injured.

The exit ramp was under construction at the time. Stantec prepared the Temporary Traffic Control Plans (“TCP”) to alert and assist drivers navigating the construction zone. FDOT mandates a “clear zone” between the lane of travel and any obstructions or obstacles on the shoulder. The clear zone required at the crash site was 24 feet. It was undisputed that the blunt end of the barrier wall was outside of the clear zone. Plaintiffs sued Stantec, arguing it should have designed a crash cushion or attenuator to protect the blunt end.

Section 337.195(3), Florida Statutes, provides a rebuttable presumption that a design engineer meets the standard of care if its plans conform to the FDOT design standards. The presumption can only be overcome with a showing of gross negligence. Plaintiffs argued Stantec could and should have done more to protect the public with “extra” safety measures, and their expert testified Stantec failed to exercise professional judgment.

CSK argued that any inquiry into what more could have or should have been done would render section 337.195(3) irrelevant; if one must try the case to learn its fate, the statutory “immunity” conferred is no immunity at all. The judge agreed and granted final summary judgment in Stantec’s favor.

CSK has a robust construction department prepared to offer you guidance and defense to any of your construction matters. Please contact any of our thirteen offices for additional information and assistance.

Our team is available to discuss the topics written here and ready to provide additional information contained in this article. Contact us for more information.

Latest News

Florida Board of Veterinary[...]

July 22, 2022
Tampa Partner, Liz Lanier, and Tampa Associate, Ashleigh Dyer, successfully defended a veterinarian client in[...]

Palm Beach County Premises[...]

July 22, 2022
Ft. Lauderdale Partner, Jami Gursky, obtained final summary judgment in Palm Beach County Circuit Court[...]

Monroe County Premises Liability[...]

July 22, 2022
Miami Partner, Jason Villares, obtained final summary judgment in Monroe County in favor of a[...]