Defense Verdict – Marion County

March 15, 2023

Orlando Partners Michael Merrill and Scott Shelton received a complete defense verdict in Marion County involving a car accident.
The Defendant/Client was a commercial garbage hauling company whose truck was making a left turn when it collided head-on with Plaintiff’s vehicle. The impact pushed Plaintiff’s vehicle backwards approximately 30 feet and was totalled as a result of the accident.

Plaintiff, who was 72 years old and had no pre-incident complaints/treatment of orthopaedic issues, underwent treatment to his knee, neck, and back from numerous doctors over the course of five years and had a surgical recommendation from a neurosurgeon for his L4 – L5.
Defendants admitted liability for the accident but contested the cause/extent of Plaintiff’s injuries. Plaintiff asked the jury for approximately $630,000. After the jury deliberated for approximately 2.5 hours, they returned with a verdict awarding Plaintiff past medical expenses of only $3,335 (which was much lower than those incurred), no money for future meds, and a finding of no permanency.

Mike Merrill
(321) 972-0022

Scott Shelton
(321) 972-0011

Our team is available to discuss the topics written here and ready to provide additional information contained in this article. Contact us for more information.

Latest News

Appellate Win on Behalf[...]

August 14, 2023
Miami Associate Francesca Stein recently obtained a favorable opinion out of the Fourth District Court[...]

Defense Verdict on Behalf[...]

August 8, 2023
Pensacola partner Grayson Miller and Miami partner Gene Kissane obtained a defense verdict following a[...]

Favorable Appellate Opinion –[...]

July 24, 2023
Miami Partner Lissette Gonzalez and Tampa Partner Mark Tinker recently obtained a favorable opinion out[...]