Eleventh Circuit Court Affirms Decision on Dismissal in Discrimination Case

November 4, 2022

Orlando Partner Therese Savona recently received a favorable opinion from the Eleventh Circuit Court of Appeals in a civil rights case involving allegations of discrimination based on religion.

The plaintiff sued a gym based on the gym’s mask mandate from December 2020 on the basis the gym failed to accommodate plaintiff’s sincerely held religious objection to the mask mandate. The gym moved to dismiss the complaint for failure to state a claim which was granted by the district court.

The plaintiff also moved for sanctions against the gym based on its arguments in the motion to dismiss which was denied by the district court. However, the district court denied this request and sanctioned the plaintiff, a recent law school graduate, by requiring the plaintiff to read the ethical rules. The district court also denied plaintiff’s motion for leave to amend his complaint as futile.

The Eleventh Circuit agreed the dismissal of the complaint was appropriate, that the plaintiff should not be provided leave to amend, and that the plaintiff was not entitled to a temporary restraining order and preliminary injunction. The appellate court also agreed with the district court that plaintiff’s motion for sanctions was frivolous and the district court correctly deny the motion for sanctions against the gym.

Therese Savona
(321) 972-0071

Our team is available to discuss the topics written here and ready to provide additional information contained in this article. Contact us for more information.

Latest News

Appellate Win on Behalf[...]

August 14, 2023
Miami Associate Francesca Stein recently obtained a favorable opinion out of the Fourth District Court[...]

Defense Verdict on Behalf[...]

August 8, 2023
Pensacola partner Grayson Miller and Miami partner Gene Kissane obtained a defense verdict following a[...]

Favorable Appellate Opinion –[...]

July 24, 2023
Miami Partner Lissette Gonzalez and Tampa Partner Mark Tinker recently obtained a favorable opinion out[...]