Reduced Verdict – Duval County Traffic Accident

March 7, 2023

Ft. Laurdale Partner, Mirelis Castilla, and Jacksonville Partner, Christopher Walsh, recently obtained a favorable verdict in a 5 day trial in Duval County last week. This was a motor vehicle accident occurring in 2021. Plaintiff’s pushed for an expediated trial due to the age of the Defendant. Liability was not disputed.

Plaintiff was a very active individual who was back at work within a short period of time and was not claiming any lost wages, past or future. She alleged a cervical disc herniation resulting in conservative treatment and steroid injections. Plaintiff’s expert presented a lifecare plan over $300,000. Defense presented a counter lifecare plan of $170,000. Defense CME doctor gave Plaintiff a permanent injury to the cervical spine to which the Court granted directed verdict on same.

Defense argued the cause of the herniation was pre-existing and future care should be limited to reasonable treatment listed in their lifecare plan. Plaintiff waived past medicals and asked the jury for $2.333 MIL. The Jury deliberated for few hours and returned a verdict of $245,782.

Mirelis Castilla
(954) 343-3931

Christopher Walsh
(904) 672-4053

Our team is available to discuss the topics written here and ready to provide additional information contained in this article. Contact us for more information.

Latest News

Defense Verdict – Brevard[...]

March 16, 2023
Orlando Partners, Michele Morales and Brian Fery, obtained a complete defense verdict in Brevard County.[...]

Defense Verdict – Marion[...]

March 15, 2023
Orlando Partners Michael Merrill and Scott Shelton received a complete defense verdict in Marion County[...]

Favorable Personal Injury Verdict[...]

March 7, 2023
Tampa Partners Aram Megerian and Dorice Voecks obtained a favorable verdict in the Middle District[...]