Judge Dismisses Plaintiff’s Case After Fraud Discovery in Hendry County, FL

CSK Defense
Fort Myers Associate Mark Bowers

Case Summary
This case involved a Plaintiff who claimed to have suffered a traumatic brain injury in a car accident. During her deposition, the Plaintiff denied having any prior head injuries, being a victim of violent crime, or experiencing blunt force trauma before the accident. However, the Defendant’s legal team uncovered medical records showing that the Plaintiff had previously suffered a traumatic brain injury and brain bleed after being struck with a crowbar in a violent incident in 2020.

Defense Strategy
The defense’s approach centered on thorough investigation and evidence gathering. With diligent paralegal support, they secured medical records from multiple providers, which contradicted the Plaintiff’s sworn testimony. These records revealed a history of significant head injuries that the Plaintiff had denied under oath. Based on this evidence, the defense filed a motion for fraud, arguing that the Plaintiff had intentionally misled the court and the Defendant about her medical history.

Verdict
The court dismissed Plaintiff’s case with prejudice after uncovering clear evidence of fraud. This outcome not only ends the case permanently but also highlights the strength of the Defendant’s legal strategy, built on meticulous record gathering and a commitment to exposing dishonesty in the courtroom. It’s a decisive win for the defense and a reminder of the importance of truthfulness in legal proceedings.